Does My Baby Have Reflux or Colic?

baby reflux colicReflux and colic are similar conditions that put babies in a lot of discomfort. So how do you tell them apart? More importantly, what can you do if your baby is affected? This guide will help you answer those questions.

Symptoms of reflux
Symptoms of colic
Helping a baby with reflux
Helping a baby with colic

Symptoms of Gastroesophageal Reflux

Gastroesophageal Reflux Disease (GERD) in infants is different from acid reflux in adults. Infant reflux is simply frequent “spitting up”, which many babies do. It’s estimated that up to 35% of the 4 million babies born annually in the United States suffers at least mild reflux. If your baby spits up occasionally, it’s nothing to be concerned about. The symptoms of GERD tend to be more severe:

  • Repeated vomiting
  • Spitting up with little or no apparent effort
  • Frequent wet coughing
  • Apparent respiratory problems, such as wheezing.

If your baby suffers any of the above symptoms, it may be reflux.

Symptoms of Baby Colic

Baby colic (also called infantile colic) is a condition in which an otherwise healthy baby cries or appears stressed for long periods without any obvious cause. Typically, it manifests during the first month of life and continues until the baby is 3-4 months old, though rare cases have persisted up to a year. The medical criteria specify that babies with colic cry or fuss for at least three hours, at least three times a week, for the first three weeks of life. That being said, many doctors believe that a baby can have colic without quite meeting these symptoms, especially the 3-hour rule. A more general set of symptoms of baby colic include:

  • Sudden onset of crying or fussiness without any discernible reason
  • Intense crying that lasts for hours
  • Hunching and other signs of intestinal/GI discomfort
  • The frequency and intensity increases over a course of weeks
  • Symptoms happen more often or more acutely in the late afternoon or early evening.

The late afternoon / early evening fussiness is common among babies, even those without colic. We asked our pediatrician about it, and even he was uncertain as to the reason. He did point out that the early evening is when babies (1) tend to get more tired, as they don’t sleep as well during the day, and (2) usually have gone a longer time without substantial feeding, which usually happens in the morning and at night. The confluence of these factors may explain why many babies are colicky at around 4 or 5 p.m.

Helping A Baby with Reflux

There’s lots you can do to deal with babies with mild reflux. The most important thing is to minimize the stress placed on your baby’s tummy. This means that you should avoid overfeeding and try to burp your baby at least twice during feedings. You should also keep your baby in a somewhat upright position for at least half an hour after he’s eaten. You can hold him, of course, or put him in a baby bouncer or Bumbo-type seat. Always put a burp cloth or towel on your shoulder when you’re holding the baby or burping him, as infants with reflux tend to spit up a lot.

Helping A Baby with Colic

The jury is still out on the cause of baby colic. While gas bubbles in the stomach or digestive tract have always been a popular theory, it is clear that the set of causes goes well beyond that. Worse, many of the standard treatments for digestive discomfort — simethicone, for example — seem to only offer temporary relief or none at all. Wikipedia recommends that babies with colic be treated instead with the five S’s:

  • Swaddling your baby to keep him warm and help him feel secure.
  • Side or stomach positions to comfort your infant while holding him (he should only be put on his back to sleep).
  • Shushing or sound. Make a soft shushing noise near your baby’s ear, or use something else to make white noise in the baby’s room.
  • Swing the baby back and forth in tiny movements. Make sure he’s tucked close to you, and support the head and neck.
  • Sucking. Give the baby a breast, pacifier, or a (washed) fingertip to suck on.

You’ll notice that these are all baby soothing techniques, nothing more. Unfortunately, since the medical basis of colic remains understood, there are not many advanced treatment options. No matter what the experts say, I recommend that you try gas relief drops with simethicone (Mylicon) and gripe water to see if they make a difference for your baby.

What To Read Next

If you like this article, you might want to subscribe by e-mail or RSS so that you’re notified when new content is posted.